The difference between mechanical and chemical filtration in water treatment

Clean water is an essential basic need for human life.

However, along with population growth and industrialization, the quality of water available for household consumption is deteriorating. Therefore, household water treatment is becoming increasingly important to ensure the availability of safe and healthy water for families. In this article, we will take an in-depth look at the two main methods in household water treatment: mechanical filtration and chemical filtration.

Household water treatment systems generally utilize water storage from municipal sources or wells, or sometimes a combination of both. This water is then pumped through filters or water softeners to remove substances such as iron, silica, or other contaminants. Some systems even use reverse osmosis (RO) technology for further purification. However, before we dive into the differences between mechanical and chemical filtration, it's important to understand why household water treatment is necessary.

The source of water used by households can vary. For those using well water, common issues faced are iron, manganese, and possible bacterial contamination due to leaks from septic tanks. On the other hand, municipal water that comes from rivers can also be contaminated by household and industrial waste. Even the use of refillable drinking water is not free from problems, such as the potential presence of microplastics.

Given these challenges, an often-recommended solution is a whole-house or point of entry (POE) water treatment system that can handle water from wells or the city. These systems not only ensure water quality for drinking, but also for other household needs such as bathing, washing, and cooking.

Mechanical Filtration: Water Treatment Basics

Source: IQSdirectory.com

Mechanical filtration is the first and most fundamental step in household water treatment. It works on the principle of physical filtration, where solid particles larger than the pore size of the filter are retained. Some common types of mechanical filters used in domestic water treatment systems include:

1. Sediment Filters: These filters are typically used as a pre-filter to remove large particles such as sand, silt, and other impurities. Sediment filters are available in a variety of pore sizes, ranging from 50 microns to 5 microns.
2. Active Carbon Filters:While also involving a chemical process, activated carbon filters work mechanically to absorb organic contaminants, chlorine, and substances that cause unpleasant odors and tastes in water.
3. Multimedia Filters: These filters use multiple layers of filtration media such as sand, anthracite, and garnet to remove various particle sizes.
4. Ultrafiltration (UF):UF membranes have very small pores (about 0.01 microns) that can remove bacteria, viruses, and even some large organic molecules.

One of the main advantages of mechanical filtration is its ability to remove solid particles without the use of chemical additives. This makes this method relatively safe and environmentally friendly. However, mechanical filtration has limitations in removing dissolved contaminants such as heavy metal ions or salts.

For more advanced filtration systems, we can use products like Pentair Pentek cartridge filters that have been NSF-certified for various water treatment applications. This filter can be used as part of a multistage filtration system to increase the effectiveness of water treatment.

Chemical Filtration: Improving Water Quality

source: carewater.solutions

Chemical filtration involves the use of chemicals or chemical processes to remove or alter contaminants in water. This method is often used in conjunction with mechanical filtration to achieve optimal water treatment results. Some commonly used chemical filtration methods in domestic water treatment include:

1. Chlorination: The addition of chlorine to water is the most commonly used disinfection method. Chlorine is effective in killing bacteria and other pathogenic microorganisms. While some people dislike the smell and taste of chlorine, it is important to remember that this odor is actually a sign of well-disinfected water.
2. Water Softening: This process uses ion exchange resins to remove the calcium and magnesium ions that cause water hardness. Products such as Purolite ion exchange resin can be used for this process.
3. Oxidation: This process is used to remove iron and manganese from water. Chemicals such as chlorine, potassium permanganate, or ozone are used to oxidize these metals to a form that can be mechanically filtered.
4. Oxidation: This process is used to remove iron and manganese from water.
5. Adsorption: This method uses materials such as activated carbon to adsorb organic and inorganic contaminants. Calgon's coal-based activated carbon is one product that can be used for this process.
6. Reverse Osmosis (RO): Although RO also involves a physical process, it is considered a chemical filtration method due to its ability to remove dissolved ions and other small molecules. Household RO systems like Pentair Merlin Undersink Reverse Osmosis can be used to produce high-quality drinking water.

Chemical filtration has the advantage of removing contaminants that mechanical filtration alone cannot address. However, the use of chemicals in water treatment also requires special attention to ensure the dosage is appropriate and does not cause unwanted side effects.

Choosing the Right Water Treatment System

Choosing the right water treatment system for a household depends on several factors, including source water quality, water needs, and available budget. Here are some important considerations in choosing a water treatment system:

1. Water Quality Analysis: The first step is to conduct a water quality test to find out the types of contaminants present. This will help determine the type of treatment required.
2. System Capacity: Consider your household's daily water needs to select a system with the appropriate capacity.
3. Contaminant Type: If the source water contains a lot of sediment, focus on mechanical filtration. If the problem is hardness or dissolved contaminants, chemical filtration may be more appropriate.
4. Operating Costs: Consider the cost of maintenance and periodic replacement of filters or filtration media.
5. Space Available: Some systems require considerable space, while others are more compact.
6. Special Needs: If there are special needs such as microplastic-free water, consider RO or ultrafiltration systems.

For a comprehensive water treatment system, a combination of mechanical and chemical filtration often provides the best results. For example, the system may start with a sediment filter, followed by an activated carbon filter, water softening, and end with UV disinfection or chlorination. For drinking water, a final stage with RO can be added to ensure very high water quality.

Important Components in a Household Water Treatment System

In addition to filters and filtration media, there are several other important components to consider in a household water treatment system:

Storage Tanks

These tanks are used to store water from the source (well or city) before it is treated. Proper selection of the tank is important to maintain water quality.

Pump

Pumps are used to move water through the treatment system. Selection of efficient pumps such as Flint and Walling RO pumps can help save energy.

Automatic Valve

These valves control the flow of water through various stages of treatment. Products like Aquamatic automatic valves can improve system efficiency.

Pressure Tank

This tank helps maintain consistent water pressure throughout the home. Wellmate pressure storage tanks are an example of a product that can be used for this purpose.

Chemical Injection Systems

 For systems that require the addition of chemicals such as chlorine or coagulants, a chemical injection system is required. Hydropro dosing pumps can be used for this purpose.

UV Disinfection System

For additional disinfection without chemicals, UV systems such as Hydropro ultraviolet systems can be used. Proper, high-quality component selection is essential to ensure long-term water treatment system performance and reliability.

Conclusion

Household water treatment is an important investment for family health and comfort. An understanding of the differences between mechanical and chemical filtration, as well as proper system selection, can help ensure a clean and safe water supply in your home.

Mechanical filtration provides a solid foundation for removing solid particles and some other contaminants. Meanwhile, chemical filtration allows for the removal of more complex contaminants such as dissolved ions, bacteria, and organic substances. The combination of these two methods, along with quality system components, can result in a comprehensive and effective water treatment solution.

It's important to remember that there is no "one-size-fits-all" solution in household water treatment. Each home has unique needs based on water sources, usage patterns, and occupant preferences. Therefore, consultation with a water treatment professional and careful water quality analysis are highly recommended before selecting and installing a water treatment system.

With a good understanding of the principles of mechanical and chemical filtration, as well as proper selection of system components, you can ensure that your family has access to clean and safe water every day. Investing in a quality water treatment system not only improves quality of life, but also provides peace of mind regarding your family's health and well-being.

Questions and Answers

1. Is chlorinated water dangerous?

No, chlorinated water actually indicates that the water has been properly disinfected. Chlorine is a commonly used disinfectant in water treatment and is effective in killing harmful bacteria and microorganisms. While some people may not like the smell, the presence of chlorine in recommended amounts (usually around 0.5-1.0 mg/L) indicates that the water is safe for consumption. If the chlorine odor is too strong, you can use an activated carbon filter to reduce it.

2. How do I know if my household water treatment system needs to be replaced?

There are several signs that indicate that your water treatment system may need to be replaced or repaired:

• Significant decrease in water quality (unusual taste, odor, or appearance)
• Consistent decrease in water pressure
• Increased operating costs or frequency of repairs
• System age exceeding 10-15 years
• Changes in source water quality or local water regulations

3. Do reverse osmosis (RO) systems remove essential minerals from water?

Yes, RO systems do remove most minerals from water, including some beneficial minerals like calcium and magnesium. However, this does not mean RO water is harmful or unhealthy. Most of the minerals the body needs are obtained from food, not from drinking water. If you are concerned about mineral intake, you may consider an RO system with remineralization features or consume mineral-rich foods as part of a balanced diet.

References

1. Hendricks, D. W. (2006). Fundamentals of Water Treatment Unit Processes: Physical, Chemical, and Biological. CRC Press.

2. Parsons, S., & Jefferson, B. (2006). Introduction to Potable Water Treatment Processes. Blackwell Publishing.

3. Spellman, F. R. (2013). Handbook of Water and Wastewater Treatment Plant Operations. CRC Press.

4. Byrne, W. (2002). Reverse Osmosis: A Practical Guide for Industrial Users. Tall Oaks Publishing.

5. Binnie, C., & Kimber, M. (2013). Basic Water Treatment (5th Edition). ICE Publishing.